NP View: Dear Mark, you’ve got work at home to do

Soon after Mark Carney was no doubt feeling on top of the world after delivering a speech to the European Parliament on Thursday, and after being oddly mobbed for selfies, the parochial nature of Canadian politics asserted itself. Following the prime minister’s welcoming response to an offer for Canada to become the “first associate member of the EU,” Quebec Premier Christine Fréchette demanded “for Québec to be granted special status within this alliance.”

No one, not Carney, nor European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen who extended the invitation to Canada, could define what being an “associate member” actually entails, as the designation doesn’t currently exist. But Quebec is certain it wants “a formal seat at the table,” a table that also doesn’t exist.

For Fréchette, her demand is probably smart politics ahead of an Oct. 5 provincial election, but it also highlights that for as much as Carney might feel at home being feted in European capitals, or being addressed affectionately by von der Leyen with a “Dear Mark,” the mundane details of governing this often bewildering country require tending.

Beyond mollifying a gaggle of premiers, all with different interests and competing opinions on how to deal with American trade tensions, and varying levels of commitment to the Canadian project, Carney also has to figure out how to turn Canada into a functioning country with drivable roads, working ports and, presumably, a military. The premiers all have different opinions about those things too.

If von der Leyen was feeling a bit besieged after a handful of EU members objected to her offer to Canada of “associate membership,” she should try negotiating a trade deal with the provinces, even in areas where Ottawa has clear constitutional authority. Cat herders gave up on this country long ago.

In any case, we endorse the general idea of expanding Canada’s economic and security relationship with the European Union, as we also endorse the close economic and security ties Canada has with the United States.

Europe is not equivalent to authoritarian China, and pretending it is, as some critics have suggested, muddies legitimate concerns about what comes with any level of EU membership.

Full membership in the union entails aligning regulations on labour, the environment and procurement; forfeiting the right to negotiate trade deals; and adopting open borders within the bloc. The EU is also suffering intense economic stagnation and decline due to the level of rules and regulations and the sheer size of the European bureaucracy.

Some supporters of full membership suggest the EU is only marginally worse than Canada on regulation, so we wouldn’t be that much worse off, but we think that Canada should avoid that trap.

Even with these problems though, EU members are liberal democratic allies that Canada would do well to engage with at a level short of membership. Indeed, they are likely more concerned about Canada’s vulnerability to Chinese interference than Canada itself.

Luckily, based on what both Carney and von der Leyen said in their speeches, nothing on offer requires a new special designation.