Pinot Noir: The heartbreak grape

The Standard's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Kershaw Vineyard Kershaw Vineyard Douglas Blyde 1 minute ago COMMENTS International Pinot Noir Day falls on 18 August, inviting us to pull a cork. Most wines welcome such treatment. But fine Pinot can make the person holding the bottle hesitate.

At its upper reaches, Pinot is bought on allocation, moved through storage and discussed in the future tense. A sealed bottle can retain every flattering possibility. Open it and there is nowhere for the wine to hide.

This is peculiar behaviour for a drink. A watch survives the wrist; a painting remains on the wall. Wine fulfils its purpose by being poured, shared and finished. Pinot makes this awkward because its gap between magnificence and mediocrity is wider than most.

New Zealand Winegrowers marks the day. In the year to June 2025, the country exported more than eight million litres of Pinot Noir against 251 million litres of Sauvignon Blanc. Pinot is significant, though Sauvignon still does the heavy lifting.

The grape’s ancestry has been assembled from fragments. ‘Pinot’ comes from the French pin, or pine, after its pine-cone-shaped bunches; Burgundy recorded ‘Plant Fin’ in 1375. In March 2026, researchers found a 600-year-old seed from a medieval hospital latrine in Valenciennes to be genetically identical to modern Pinot Noir. Its lineage emerged through forensic work, not romance.

Marq de Villiers’s 1993 book about Calera popularised Pinot’s nickname, ‘the heartbreak grape’. Founder Josh Jensen hunted limestone before planting on remote Mount Harlan, persuaded that California could make Pinot capable of standing beside Burgundy.

He had chosen a grape with a talent for humiliating conviction. Pinot’s thin skins and compact bunches invite disease; frost, rain and heat can erase a year. André Tchelistcheff, the Russian-born, French-trained winemaker later known as Napa’s ‘Maestro’, put it with brutal economy: ‘God made Cabernet Sauvignon, but the Devil made Pinot Noir.’

A poor Pinot is raspberry water with a plank laid across it. A great one moves from cherry, raspberry and rose towards tea, earth, truffle and game. It works through fragrance rather than force, which is why it can feel complete without being heavy.

Richard Hemming MW writes that ‘no type of wine promises such ecstasy more than Pinot Noir’. The operative word is ‘promises’. More money improves the odds; it cannot alter the result.

Te Wāhi Cloudy Bay Why the cork stays in Burgundy has made this uncertainty both more local and more expensive. Vines a few strides apart can produce very different wines and vastly different bills. Revolutionary and Napoleonic inheritance laws required equal division among children, cutting holdings into strips and leaving growers with a scatter of rows rather than a single large domaine. Hence the old Burgundian line: marry for vines, divorce for love.

The Works shareholder questions chair’s New Zealand residency and home working

Burgundy’s wealth lies in a narrow run of hillside which families seldom sell.