90% of executives say AI hasn’t boosted productivity. Some are still cutting jobs

Business leaders and investors face a deepening paradox: Companies are pouring more money into artificial intelligence than ever, but they’re not seeing the gains in productivity that they expect.

Even CEOs are starting to admit this disconnect.

One Atlanta Federal Reserve study found that about 90% of executives believe AI has not yet boosted productivity at their companies.

Other evidence suggests that the broader increase in productivity seen since 2021 is more likely due to remote work or factors other than AI , like downsizing in sectors such as technology.

I study how technology is changing the way businesses operate, and the research I’ve conducted with colleagues offers an important explanation for why these expected gains don’t materialize: AI-driven layoffs and the resulting job insecurity are actively destroying the very conditions needed for AI to make workers more efficient.

In fact, these job cuts damage employee sentiment toward AI – which is one of the strongest predictors of firm productivity when AI is used.

Managers and investors should take note.

Laying off employees in the name of AI investment is a self-defeating strategy that offsets any expected productivity increase.

When layoffs are the strategy U.S. companies have poured billions of dollars into AI adoption in the hope of goosing productivity.

But our research suggests that managers should treat the AI hype with caution.

My colleagues and I analyzed millions of job satisfaction reviews and thousands of reports of corporate financial performance, as well as hundreds of AI investments and layoff announcements made by U.S. public companies over the past five years.

We discovered a clear pattern: As the frequency of AI investment announcements rises, so too do announcements of job cuts caused by AI.

This correlation is unlikely to be coincidental.

Instead, it reflects a corporate strategy that sees workforce reduction as an integral part of their AI strategy.